While creating North – and living together in Nashville – lead singer jokes that the foursome “spent, like, $40,000 on wine. Just on the wine.”
“At five, six o’clock, we’d break for dinner and things would just go south,” Thomas, 40, said in a recent interview. “And we would think it was awesome, everything we were doing was awesome, and we’d come back in and we would meet some new band out in the middle of Nashville and bring them back to the studio … and play all this crap. I know they walked away going, ‘Dude, the new record is going to suck!’ ”
“At five, six o’clock, we’d break for dinner and things would just go south,” Thomas, 40, said in a recent interview.
None of those songs made it on the album North – which may be part of the reason it debuted at No. 1 on Billboard’s 200 albums chart last week after selling 95,000 units, according to Nielsen SoundScan. The rockers recorded the album, their first release since the 2007 compilation album Exile on Mainstream, in New York, Los Angeles and “in the woods” of Nashville. They hadn’t lived together since doing so when they recorded their 12-times platinum 1996 debut, Yourself or Someone Like You.
But they said reuniting felt “natural” and the musicians began writing material while Thomas toured his second solo album in 2009.
Doucette, the band’s drummer, said they recorded more than 60 songs, and selecting the final tracks was tiresome.
“We became really overwhelmed with the material and really the amount of different directions we (could) take with the material,” he said. “Within those 60 songs there was an Americana record, there was a pop record, there was a rock record.”
Thomas added: “Not to mention you’d pass out and you’d wake up the next day and somebody would come in and be like, ‘I turned it into a ragtime record!”
The Grammy-nominated band – which includes guitarist Cook and bassist – said being in Nashville did influence their sound, though they ditched it toward the end: “We kind of decided that wasn’t the record that we were making.”
The album’s first single, the lighthearted She’s So Mean, is a departure for the rock band, best known for the hits Unwell, 3 AM and Bent.
“Our songs are lyrically a bit heavier and not as many tongue-in-cheek kind of songs, and it was kind of nice to come out with something that’s not our typical (sound),” Doucette said of the Top 40 hit.